To What Extent Has Membership Of Europe

Affected Our Political Sovereignty? Essay, Research Paper

?Inside Europe we are part of what will be a world power. The national sovereignty

we lose is more than made good by a share of the much larger sovereignty which

we get from participation in Europe.? (Michael Heseltine)

?The 1986 Single European Act and the Maastricht Treaty can be seen as further

reducing Britain?s sovereignty.? (Nugent)

Britain has been a full member of the EEC, and later the EU, since 1972. By

joining such an organisation it enjoys the benefits of a Common Market across

Europe, but surrenders some of its political sovereignty to the precedence of

European Law over Domestic Law. Indeed Britain?s political sovereignty has unquestionably

suffered a great deal due to its membership of Europe. In 1975 Tony Benn wrote

a letter to his constituents underlying the major worries of EEC membership.

Firstly he said that the Community subjects us to laws and taxes which British

government is powerless to amend or repeal, and they are passed by people not

elected by the British electorate. Furthermore he described how the EEC requires

British courts to enforce laws that have not necessarily been supported by the

British Parliament, and that Parliament does not have the power to change these

laws, even if they conflict with existing common or statute law. To add to this,

British membership imposes duties and constraints upon British governments.

This means that ministers have to discharge many of their duties, and those

that take them over are not accountable to British Parliament or public. Basically,

the EEC can use the British parliament as a layer of insulation separating them

from the British people. They therefore have no duty to remedy the grievances

of the British people, as they are not accountable to them.

Whilst Tony Benn presents an extreme example of Euro-scepticism, it is indisputable

that membership of Europe detracts from our parliamentary sovereignty. EU law

is binding on all member states and, therefore, takes precedence over British

domestic law. However, the British Parliament does have the power to at least

try to prevent the enforcement of EU law in the case of amendments to the Treaty

of Rome, but otherwise EU legislation automatically becomes law within the UK,

irrespective of the British Parliament?s opinion on it.

Unlike the other member states of the EU, the United Kingdom has a distinctive

constitution based not on a codified document but on the principle of parliamentary

sovereignty. The issue of national sovereignty is an intensively sensitive one

in British politics because of the country?s history, which has been very different

from that of continental states, and because of the different role which the

British Parliament plays from that of European Parliaments. Membership of the

European Union inevitably entails a loss ? or transfer ? of national sovereignty

in return for a share in a greater and more powerful European sovereignty. The

main institutions of the EU operate partly on a supranational level and partly

on an intergovernmental level, and it is this idea of supranational control

which seems to threaten the sovereignty of the British Parliament, and make

its policy less important and meaningful.

Sovereignty is an idea decked with tradition and prestige. Indeed, in 1885

A.V. Dicey defined parliamentary sovereignty as the right of Parliament ?to

make any law whatever; and, further, no person or body is recognised by the

law as having a right to override the legislation of Parliament.? The supremacy

of Parliament, established by the Glorious Revolution of 1688, effectively ended

when Parliament surrendered it in passing the European Communities Act in 1972.

When Britain became a member of the EEC in 1973 certain areas of policy making

were transferred to the EEC Commission and to the Council of Ministers. This

meant that if the Council approved the commission has the right to enforce its

recommendations irrespective of domestic legislation that might contradict it,

and the only way to reclaim this loss of sovereignty would be to repeal the

act of 1972 and withdraw from EC membership.

Entry into the EEC caused enormous controversy, leading to the first ever

national referendum in 1975 and the formation of the Social Democratic Party

by pro-European ex-Labour MPs in 1981. Under Maggie Thatcher, the EC was supported

as a free trade economic union but not as a ?federalist? concept moving towards

a United States of Europe. The difficulty of having greater economic integration

without greater political integration was highlighted by the Single European

Act of 1986. This act was the first comprehensive revision of the original Treaty

of Rome (1958) and while this speeded up economic integration it also strengthened

the supranational organisations such as the Council of Ministers so a

Внимание, отключите Adblock

Вы посетили наш сайт со включенным блокировщиком рекламы!
Ссылка для скачивания станет доступной сразу после отключения Adblock!

Скачать